“Islamophobia” is a word I cannot trust. It hides the truth. What we face is racism. A deep, old racism that puts people in boxes before they even speak. A racism that judges them not for who they are but for where they come from. This racism has a name—Orientalism. It has a face—the supremacy of white culture. And it has roots—roots in the power of the church, in the histories of empires, in the belief that one way of life is better than all others.

But this word, “Islamophobia,” does something dangerous. It turns the story around. It tells us that criticizing Islam is the same as hating people. It tells us that questioning religious conservatism, calling out patriarchy, and standing against the harm done in the name of religion is wrong. It takes away our voice, our right to speak against injustice, and wraps it in silence.

And this silence is not about race. It goes deeper than that. In cities across Europe, you hear the echoes of hatred. In protests for Palestine, there are chants against Jews. There are flags of Turkey and Qatar, states that have their own bloody hands in oppression. Turkey blocks clean water for a million people in Rojava, and Qatar pours money into conservative groups that spread division. Yet, all of this is accepted. All of it is tolerated under the cover of something they call “cultural relativism.”

This “relativism” is a lie. It is Orientalism wearing new clothes. It is racism hiding behind academic theories. It says, “We must respect other cultures, even if they oppress.” But what it really means is, “We will turn away from injustice as long as it doesn’t threaten us.”

When some people in the West, claiming to fight against colonialism and racism, insult an opponent of Islamic fascism in Iran so cruelly, denying their truth and spreading lies about their society, there is another kind of racism on the other side. It is the kind that sees the color of someone’s skin or the scarf on a woman’s head and, with just one look, demands that this unfortunate person from the East explain themselves.

I cannot accept this. I will not be silent. Criticizing Islam is not hate. It is asking for freedom—for women, for those who are silenced, for those who are told they must obey. It is standing against the same forces that once silenced others, whether in the name of Christianity, empire, or power.

Islamophobia, as a word, tries to confuse us. It wants us to believe that calling out harm is the same as causing it. But we must see through this trick. Racism is real. Orientalism is real. And the fight against oppression, no matter what shape it takes, is a fight we must take on with clear eyes and brave hearts.

→ The short URL: https://firenexttime.net/8p3j

Discover more from The Fire Next Time

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

Comments

6 responses to “The Dangers of Labeling: Islamophobia vs. Racism”

  1. Peter

    The attempt a redefining “Islamophobia” as “racism” has always been an issue with me. I am Islamophobic! – as I don’t like Islam. Or any other organised religion. The definition is simply in the word itself. This doesn’t mean that I am anti Muslim! Or anti anybody who follows a religion. Racism is nowhere in this issue. “Racism” is dragged in by people who want to use it as a shield against their delusional ideas. What’s next to be labeled raciest? Christianophobia?

  2. Stéphane Charbonnier (CHARB) addressed and analysed precisely what you say in his book “OPEN LETTER — On Blasphemy, Islamophobia, and the True Enemies of Free Expression” (in French: “Lettre aux escrocs de l’islamophobie qui font le jeu des racistes”).
    In English, the German title of his book reads “Letter to the hypocrites”.

  3. David Walker

    Let’s take a look:
    2005 7 July central London bombings 52 killed 700 injured
    2007 30 June Glasgow airport bombing 5 people injured
    2010 14 May stabbing of Stephen Timms
    2013 22 May Lee Rigby decapitated
    2017 22 March Westminster Bridge attack 4 killed 50 injured
    2017 22 May Manchester Arena bombing 22 dead (including 10 children,) 139 injured
    2017 3 June London Bridge attack 8 people killed 48 wounded
    2017 15 September Parsons Green bombing 30 people injured
    2018 14 August Westminster car attack 2 injured
    2018 31 December Mahdi Mohamud stabbings 3 injured
    2019 29 November London Bridge stabbing 2 killed 3 injured
    2020 20 June Reading stabbings 3 killed 3 injured
    2021 21 March Batley teacher forced into hiding
    2021 15 October murder of David Amess MP
    2021 14 November Liverpool Woman’s hospital bombing one injured
    2022 9 June Lady of Heaven pulled from cinemas
    2023 2 March mother desperately pleads for her 14 year old autistic son who dropped a koran
    2023 8 October onwards posters of missing British citizens held as hostages removed
    2023 15 October Hartlepool stabbing of 70 year old
    2023 4 November child verbally abused for buying a McDonalds
    2023 11 November poppy sellers intimidated at London station
    2023 15 November Jewish family confronted over McDonalds
    2023 26 December Arson attack on Mike Freer’s office
    2024 7 June attack on Jewish schoolboys at Belsize Park
    2024 25 July British Army officer Mark Teeton stabbed
    1970 to present at least 2,000 victims of rape gangs (girls 11 to 16) in Rotherham, Rochdale, Keighley, Newcastle, Peterborough, Oxford, Aylesbury, Bristol..
    A phobia is an uncontrollable, irrational, and lasting fear of a certain object, situation, or activity.
    What is irrational about being seriously worried about the common property of all the above?

  4. Alex Watson

    For two important reasons, Islamophobia is a nonsense term. To begin with, a phobia of any kind is defined as an irrational fear or aversion. What the term suggests is that fear of, or aversion to, Islam is irrational by definition. Given that the stated aim of Islam is to dictate to the entire world what they are allowed to believe, backed up with a willingness to use violence and terrorism to achieve those aims, fear of Islam would seem to be perfectly rational.

    Secondly, the way that the term is used deliberately moves the focus away from Islam itself to an irrational fear of and aversion to Muslims, comparable to anti-Semitism for Jews, and conflates it with racism. Islam is not a race, but a belief system, with adherents of all skin colours and nationalities; in India for example, Muslims and Hindus are genetically indistinguishable. In this regard, the term is simply another weaponised trope in Islam’s longstanding record of attempting to put itself beyond criticism, not only for Muslims, but the whole world.

  5. Judith Brennan

    Phobia: ‘irrational fear, horror or aversion’ according to etymonline. I don’t understand why this term has become current. Does the word imply that we can’t possibly understand Islam and hence criticise only irrationally? Or does it imply that Islam is exotic and distant from our own experience? Phobia is a dangerous word. It both disables criticism and alienates us from those around us who practise their religion.

  6. One Tawny Stranger

    Agreed. As an ex-muslim I can attest white supremacists don’t actually care what religion you are, and most of them can’t tell the difference. It’s race and culture they pay attention to. Hating Islam doesn’t change the melanin content in my skin, and criticising religion is what we should all be doing – including members of religion.

What you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Support The Fire Next Time

My journey in creating this space was deeply inspired by James Baldwin's powerful work,
"The Fire Next Time". Like Baldwin, who eloquently addressed themes of identity, race, and the human condition, this blog aims to be a beacon for open, honest, and sometimes uncomfortable discussions on similar issues.

Support The Fire Next Time and becoming a patron

Support The Fire Next Time by becoming a patron and help me grow and stay independent and editorially free for only €5 a month.

You can also support this work via PayPal.

PayPal
Substack
Youtube
Facebook
Instagram
X

Discover more from The Fire Next Time

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading